Monster Hunter Nation

SAD PUPPIES 3: The Slatening?

Slate-ening? Oh well, run with it. Here is our suggested slate!

Brad Torgersen is this year’s banner carrier in our ongoing war against Puppy Related Sadness. Now that the registrations for memberships to nominate for the Hugo are closed, here is what the Evil League of Evil authors came up with in discussion.  Here is the list, and I’ll talk about the philosophy/strategy below.

https://bradrtorgersen.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/sad-puppies-3-the-2015-hugo-slate/

Best Novel
The Dark Between the Stars – Kevin J. Anderson – TOR
Trial by Fire – Charles E. Gannon – BAEN
Skin Game – Jim Butcher – ROC
Monster Hunter Nemesis – Larry Correia – BAEN
Lines of Departure – Marko Kloos – 47 North (Amazon)

Best Novella
“Flow” – Arlan Andrews Sr. – Analog magazine November 2014
“One Bright Star to Guide Them” – John C. Wright – Castalia House
“Big Boys Don’t Cry” – Tom Kratman – Castalia House

Best Novelette
“The Journeyman: In the Stone House” – Michael F. Flynn – Analog magazine June 2014
“The Triple Sun: A Golden Age Tale” – Rajnar Vajra – Analog magazine July/Aug 2014
“Championship B’tok” – Edward M. Lerner – Analog magazine Sept 2014
“Ashes to Ashes, Dust to Dust, Earth to Alluvium” – Gray Rinehart – Orson Scott Card’s InterGalactic Medicine Show

Best Short Story
“Goodnight Stars” – Annie Bellet – The Apocalypse Triptych
Tuesdays With Molakesh the Destroyer” – Megan Grey – Fireside Fiction
“Totaled” – Kary English – Galaxy’s Edge magazine
“On A Spiritual Plain” – Lou Antonelli – Sci Phi Journal #2
“A Single Samurai” – Steve Diamond – Baen Big Book of Monsters

Best Related Work
“Letters from Gardner” – Lou Antonelli – Merry Blacksmith Press
“Transhuman and Subhuman: Essays on Science Fiction and Awful Truth” – John C. Wright – Castalia House
“THE HOT EQUATIONS: THERMODYNAMICS AND MILITARY SF” – Ken Burnside
“Wisdom From My Internet” – Michael Z. Williamson
“Why Science is Never Settled” – Tedd Roberts – BAEN

Best Graphic Story
“Reduce Reuse Reanimate (Zombie Nation book #2) – Carter Reid – (independent)

Best Dramatic Presentation (Long Form)
“The Lego Movie” – Phil Lord, Christopher Miller
“Guardians of the Galaxy” – James Gunn
“Interstellar” – Christopher Nolan
“The Maze Runner” – Wes Ball

Best Dramatic Presentation (Short Form)
Grimm – ” Once We Were Gods” – NBC
The Flash – “The Flash (pilot)” – The CW
Adventure Time – “The Prince Who Wanted Everything” – Cartoon Network
Regular Show – “Saving Time” – Cartoon Network

Best Editor (Long Form)
Toni Weisskopf – BAEN
Jim Minz – BAEN
Anne Sowards – ACE/ROC
Sheila Gilbert – DAW

Best Editor (Short Form)
Mike Resnick – Galaxy’s Edge magazine
Edmund R. Schubert – Orson Scott Card’s InterGalactic Medicine Show
Jennifer Brozek (Shattered Shields)
Bryan Thomas Schmidt (Shattered Shields)

Best Professional Artist
Carter Reid
Jon Eno
Alan Pollack
Nick Greenwood

Best Semiprozine
Orson Scott Card’s InterGalactic Medicine Show
Abyss & Apex
Andromeda Spaceways In-Flight Magazine

Best Fanzine
Tangent SF On-line – Dave Truesdale
Elitist Book Reviews – Steve Diamond
The Revenge of Hump Day – Tim Bolgeo

Best Fancast
“The Sci Phi Show” – Jason Rennie
Dungeon Crawlers Radio
Adventures in SF Publishing

Best Fan Writer
Matthew David Surridge (Black Gate)
Jeffro Johnson
Amanda Green
Cedar Sanderson
Dave Freer

The John W. Campbell Award
Jason Cordova
Kary English
Eric S. Raymond

##

Now let’s talk STRATEGIC Puppies.

These are my suggested nominations. I am under no delusions that you guys do exactly what I suggest. 🙂 (seriously, it is like herding cats!). But I would encourage you to take a look at these, and consider nominating all of them. Everybody up there is someone who the ELoE talked about. Many of these are deserving, worthy types, who would basically be ignored because they don’t appease the SJW clique. I’ll share with you some of our reasoning.

After accomplishing my goals for SP2 of getting the SJWs to have a giant, public freak out demonstrating their political biases (accomplished, hoo boy, was that ever accomplished!) and auditing the vote process (accomplished, I saw zero evidence of dishonesty from the WorldCon people) I was ready to hang it up and not do an SP3. However, as a result of the giant public SJW come apart, I got contacted by a lot of people, fans and creators both, encouraging me to keep going.

See, the Hugos are broken. Everybody who is sane and paying attention realizes that it is just a popularity contest that has come to be dominated by one tiny insular group. The Hugos are supposed to mean something. They’re supposed to represent what ALL of fandom thinks is awesome. Many of the regular voters still treat it seriously, but they’re outnumbered. Hell, even the people benefitting from the Hugo’s current state will admit that it is broken, only they do so privately, and certainly not in front of the unwashed masses who like things like fun or enjoyment. (that’s you guys!) 🙂

Last year, I got most of my suggested nominees on the ballot. I basically just listed who I was voting for, and I voted based upon what I liked. However, we all learned some interesting things from the resulting SJW freak out. I nominated people ranging from fire breathing right wing curmudgeons, to mushy moderates, and a few that I honestly had no clue what their personal beliefs were. However, the SJWs immediately labeled every single one of them as a racist, homophobic, right wing, hate-monger of hatey-hate-hate, and how this wasn’t about me bringing some popular relevance back to the Hugos, but rather an attempt to keep women and minorities out of publishing. We all know that is crap, but that’s what they ran with.

Hell, they attacked poor liberal democrat Dan Wells as a racist Neo-Con, all because I thought his Warmachine novella was amazing (and normally media tie in fiction can’t buy a Hugo to save its life, regardless of how good it is).

So this year we are expanding the slate to encompass an even wider cross section of people who would normally be shunned. A lot of thought went into this, and I’ve got stuff to do, so today I’ll illustrate our though process by going over just one category. Let’s start with the big category of best novel:

Jim Butcher for Skin Game, because how can one of the most popular authors on earth, who is like the godfather and poster boy of an entire friggin’ genre, who has produced some truly incredible works of art, then get ignored by an award which is supposed to represent “best”?  Oh wait… But they’ll say that Jim totally got a Hugo nom before! For Best RELATED WORK for a Dresden Files graphic novel… Oh hell no. That’s not how Sad Puppies rolls.

When I tell fans who don’t pay much attention to the WorldCon circle that Butcher, friggin’ BUTCHER! can’t get a Hugo, they’re stunned.  I don’t know. Is that so crazy? Maybe he’s too popular? What’s next? Are they going to nominate Matt Damon for an Oscar? Only Jim is way more talented than Matt Damon (and better looking. Go Jim).  And Skin Game is one of his best.

Kevin J. Anderson for The Dark Between the Stars, because how the hell can a genre fixture with 23 million books in print get ignored for decades? He’s one of the most popular authors alive. He is also one of the most helpful professionals in our business, who goes above and beyond the call of duty to help new writers succeed in the business.  However, KJA (who is certainly no right winger!) can’t get nominated to save his life. See, Kevin commits the unforgivable sin of doing this stuff for a living and treating it like his job. He puts fan enjoyment ahead of cause of the day message fic, and then cranks out works. He gets a bad rap for writing lots of media tie in fiction (and how could Star Wars or Dune ever possibly represent *real* sci-fi?).

Oh, don’t worry, they’ll point at Kevin and say that he’s a hack because of the quality of some media tie in fiction that he wrote to spec, the same way last time they talked about the flaws in my first novel even though it was my 11th that was nominated. Here’s the thing. Kevin is a damned fine author. Read the book. He deserves the recognition.

Trial by Fire from Chuck Gannon. Now last year, I put up a bunch of really talented authors, and they immediately started taking flack, because OBVIOUSLY I wouldn’t have had to push these authors if they were actually *good* writers… (Holy shit, I can’t even begin to wrap my brain around how dumb that is)  So here’s the thing, World, meet English Professor and Compton Crook Literary Award Winner Chuck Friggin’ Gannon, who in addition to being a master wordsmith, also knows how to write knock your socks off action adventure hard sci-fi which is a sort of Bourne Identity meets big idea interstellar warfare. You are welcome.

Because yeah… I can’t wait until Damien Walter explains how guys like Chuck Gannon and John C. Wright aren’t *real* writers. 🙂

Oh, but wait… There’s more. Because I love listening to the literati sneer at those of us who started out self-published, Marko Kloos has Lines of Departure. Marko was the SP2 nominee for the Campbell for best new author, and he actually got nominated, but had a short story sale far enough back it made him ineligible. The dude has serious skills.

After only a few years he is one of the most popular authors in indy sci-fi. His gritty space opera series has been a huge hit, and when I say huge, you guys remember my Alphabetical List of Author Success? http://monsterhunternation.com/2014/07/24/the-official-alphabetical-list-of-author-success/ Well, he’s up there on the D List with me, and at the rate he’s going should hit C soon. C is where your royalty checks buy Aston Martins. To put his popularity into perspective, indy published Marko Kloos sells more books quarterly than last year’s Hugo winner has sold in total.

And here’s the kicker. All those books are REALLY GOOD. No stunts, no gimmicks, no checking to see what social justice victim boxes they can mark, just the best damned books of the year (lots of suggestions for it, but the Martian wasn’t eligible). By authors new and old, but all of remarkable talent.

Then there’s me. I actually told Brad and the rest of the ELoE that I was perfectly fine with Monster Hunter Nemesis not being on the ballot. Because when the SJWs aren’t blaming my motivations on homophobia or racism or something, then obviously SP was all about me trying to buy myself a Hugo Award (seriously that’s dumb, I did statistical analysis most of my life, so knew going in the odds of winning were nil).  Plus, believe it or not, I really don’t enjoy having mobs of angry SJWs telling tens of thousands of complete strangers that I’m a wife beating, rape apologist. I’m perfectly happy to bow out and screw with them from the sidelines.

Then the ELoE told me tough luck, and that if I dropped out, my fans (who make up the back bone of the growing Sad Puppies contingent) would get mad at me. Plus, John Wright said that MHN was my best book, and his vote for best book of 2014. And you really can’t argue with somebody who writes like John.

Though it will be funny to hear them say this all a stunt for me personally to get a Hugo to satisfy my own ego, when I’m nominating myself against SKIN GAME! 😀

Later on we’ll talk more about the other categories in depth, but here’s the thing, in some of these smaller categories, the nominees have become downright silly.

Take a look at our Best Related Work category. The usual nominees are things like Transsexual WereSeals love Dr. Who. We’re putting up big brain stuff relating to milSF, the nature of mankind, the history of writing, and my personal favorite in that category is one of the most respected neuro-scientists in the world’s essay about the value of scientific inquiry.  Basically the usual stuff looks childish in comparison. But of course, we’ve suggested a collection of Mad Mike insulting people, because the Evil League of Evil does like to have fun.

In the novellas, novelettes, and short stories, look through those. I don’t think we have a single dinosaur love story. I do like that in Fanzine we’ve got a guy who the SJWs lied about and ran out of a con as part of their witch trials.

Quick look at Editor. Toni Weisskopf is one of the most respected editors there is. Even if you absolutely hate some of her authors (like me!) you’ve got to admit that she has been one of the most prolific, successful, talented, and all around bad ass editors in the business, not to mention a lifelong fan, who has done more for fandom than damn near anybody else alive, and she’s been doing this forever.

But did you know that she had never gotten a single Hugo nomination before Sad Puppies? None. Zip. Zero. Meanwhile, the favorite editor of the SJW crowd? I think he has ten.

There’s a blog that hates me and constantly misconstrues what Sad Puppies is about. If I recall correctly it has something like TWENTY EIGHT Hugo nominations.

That’s why I’m doing this.

So check it out. Mull it over. We’ll be posting more about this later.

I Need Your Help (gathering links to SJW attacks in sci-fi for a news reporter)
My schedule at SLC FanX

Leave a Reply

213 Comments on "SAD PUPPIES 3: The Slatening?"

Notify of
avatar

John Overath
Guest
John Overath
1 year 5 months ago

Will have to check some of these others out. If they are anywhere near as good as Skin Game and MHN then those are some bad ass books!

rustypaladin
Guest
rustypaladin
1 year 5 months ago

Now convince Toni to actually submit a resume or whatever the proper term is when she gets nominated. I know she doesn’t care but the rest of us do. And don’t let Jim Minz bow out either. 🙂

Dawn Dreams
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

“I don’t think we have a single dinosaur love story.”

Bbbbut what about John Wright’s “The Queen of the Tyrant Lizards”?
http://www.scifiwright.com/2014/11/the-queen-of-the-tyrant-lizards/

TomT
Guest
TomT
1 year 5 months ago

Wait Larry isn’t doing dinosaur slash fic?

John Rose
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

A most touching and romantic tale, that…

And the bad guys get… well, one ought to read it oneself to appreciate the… flavor of the story, shall we say?

🙂

Austin
Guest
Austin
1 year 5 months ago

To anyone who got their application in at the last minute, they’re running behind and won’t have you in the system for about a week. Good news is submissions are open until March, so plenty of time.

saintonge235
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Hey, where the FUCK is Sarah Hoyt’s “My Last Post on SFWA Pinky Swear”? That masterpiece has got to be in the best related work category!

http://accordingtohoyt.com/2014/02/18/my-last-post-on-sfwa-pinky-swear/

Daddy Warpig
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
Nominating Rich Burlew, Order of the Stick: Blood Runs In The Family. Because he KNOWS story, and doesn’t preach politics, and he’s damn good at what he does. It’s a measure about how damaged genre fiction’s reputation has become, that I’ve read few to none of the nominees above. (And so can’t nominate them myself.) Butcher, Wright, some Korea guy, but none of the rest. It’s about trust, and the SJW’s have destroyed mine. (Not worth wasting my time on patronizing, preachy BS SF.) Hence I try out few new authors, unless they come well-recommended. (Dan Wells and Brian McLellan… Read more »
John C Wright
Guest
John C Wright
1 year 5 months ago

“BS SF” Daddy Warpig, that is the best acronym ever. The truth in advertising laws should require the Science Fiction Writers of America to change their name, so that their initials will hereafter be BSSFWA.

Daddy Warpig
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

High praise from a founding member of the Evil League of Evil.

Thank you, sir! : )

BSSFWA. I’ll have to remember to use that.

Rob Hobart
Guest
Rob Hobart
1 year 5 months ago

“…and doesn’t preach politics”

Except, sorry, he DOES preach politics, of the most contemptible SJW variety. Rich thinks D&D is “racist” because the bad guys have green skin. He has posted repeated tirades about this in his forum over the last two-three years.
I put up with it as long as he kept it out of the comic itself. But after strip #959 (see Wallbanger’s post below) I’d had enough. Haven’t read a strip since then.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago

I take it that Burlew is insisting now that you just shouldn’t be allowed to do the manichean thing with orcs that are evil because they are orcs?

Perhaps we should be warry of lawsuits from defamed Nazis and imperial stormtroopers.

In the last game that I ran that had orcs, the orcs were the irredeemable creation of an evil god, and I’m fine with that, but one certainly could construct a story that challenges that assumption. What if an orc chooses to come into the light?

Rob Hobart
Guest
Rob Hobart
1 year 5 months ago
Yeah, I was fine with the depiction of humanoids as not auto-evil in the actual OotS story, because that was how he constructed his world and it fit into the overall storyline he was presenting. There are lots of interesting tales one can tell by using that premise. My problem was with the forum posts where he proclaimed that “default” D&D was inherently racist, that anyone who disagreed with him on that topic was despicable, that he was ashamed of his earlier jokes about Haley’s sexiness, that he shouldn’t have let Haley and he female rival “slut-shame” each other, etc,… Read more »
Daddy Warpig
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

SJW are quite adept at abusing social pressures to compel compliance with their ideology. The only people who seem able to resist are the obdurate, the committed, and the cantankerous.

Sad to see Rich succumbing to such pressure, but all Leftists are vulnerable to it, ideologically. SJW preach Leftism, with an extreme authoritarian bent. Leftists have to be even MORE contrary to resist SJW slander, disapproval, and ostracism.

If he continues pushing SJW cant in the future, it will ruin his work. That’d be tragic, because OOTS is great.

Still going with the nom, though, because there’s no politics in this work.

judgedeadd
Guest
judgedeadd
1 year 5 months ago

Did he turn preachy, now? Well that’s disappointing. Something similar happened in Gunnerkrigg Court. A captivating comic set in a world of mysterious technology and magic lore, and then suddenly there’s an entire chapter where one of the major characters enters a lesbian relationship, and another character delivers a (cheesy) speech about how There’s Nothing Wrong With That. I can only assume that further down the line we’ll get an eye-stinging story arc about Evil Homophobes or something.

Kathryn
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
He also wrote in the commentary in BRitF that Tarquin, who is one of the most grotesquely evil villains I’ve read, is a stand-in for heterosexual white males everywhere. The scene where Tarquin is left in the desert screaming after Elan that this isn’t how the story is supposed to go (which, at the time, I thought was a great scene and underlined Tarquin’s particular insanity) is, according to the commentary, supposed to represent the rage of heterosexual white males in response to OotS being a story in which a black male is the leader of a party, a female… Read more »
Rob Hobart
Guest
Rob Hobart
1 year 5 months ago

“He also wrote in the commentary in BRitF that Tarquin, who is one of the most grotesquely evil villains I’ve read, is a stand-in for heterosexual white males everywhere.”

UGH. I didn’t buy the collection (since I’d stopped reading by then), so I missed that, but it further affirms my judgment that Burlew’s gone full-retard SJW. A disgusting collapse of a once-great webcomic.

Wallbanger7110
Guest
Wallbanger7110
1 year 5 months ago

@Kathryn: That actually made print? Wow. Just wow.

Funny how none of this started coming to the surface until AFTER he’d gotten his big Kickstarter payday.

Kathryn
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
Here are his exact words, so you can judge for yourself and not rely solely on my interpretation: [following some discussion of Tarquin’s issues with accepting reality] “It’s easy to imagine that as a younger man, Tarquin was more able to bend his own perception to fit the reality of the situation, but as he gets older he seems to have lost that flexibility. The uncertainty scares him, and so he must hold his grip onto his vision even tighter. “In this way, Tarquin is also symbolic of an older time when stories were likely to be more formulaic or… Read more »
Wallbanger7110
Guest
Wallbanger7110
1 year 5 months ago

Oops, replied to the wrong subthread. The “Good thing I have brown hair or I’d REALLY have been insulted. 😀 ” line was supposed to be here.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Strawmen are easy to build, and demolish. That’s why they’re popular.

60guilders
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Straight.
White.
Male.
Loves/loved OOTS.
Is confused by Burlew’s apparent idiocy.

Patrick Chester
Guest
Patrick Chester
1 year 5 months ago
*reads Burlew’s quoted material* I’ve been enjoying the strip for quite a while now and somehow managed to simply enjoy the story and the characters because it was well written. Amusing most of the time, sad sometimes (“hi roy… wanna play blocks with me?”) and sometimes even awesome. Silly me, I guess I was supposed to be acting like a “typical” straight white man instead and get all upset because the party leader is *gasp* a black man. Instead I see him as a Lawful (Sarcastic) Good hero trying to do the right thing and when he fails, he… tries… Read more »
Julie Frost (@JulieCFrost)
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I know Brad recused himself, but I would love love love if The Chaplain’s War got nominated for best novel, because damn. I have a checkbox labeled “treats religion and religious characters without disdain,” and he (and Butcher!) mark that one quite nicely.

av willis
Guest
av willis
1 year 5 months ago

Seriously, he was frigging robbed last year

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Yeah, I wish he hadn’t recused himself. TCW was really, really good. The sort of novel that used to win these awards.

VD
Guest
VD
1 year 5 months ago

In case you were not aware, Mr. Torgersen’s work is up for Best Novel on the Rabid Puppies slate, which is similar to Sad Puppies, but is even more offensive to SJWs, pinkshirts, and various and sundry other rabbit breeds.

James May
Guest
James May
1 year 5 months ago

Communists are thieves.

Brad R. Torgersen
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I may have recused myself from SP3 but there is nothing to prevent people from voting for “The Chaplain’s War” for Best Novel anyway. I didn’t want to give free ammo to the whole, “Torgersen is just slumming for a Hugo!” argument. Really, I am cool with not being on the short list this time. But if readers want me there, who am I to argue with the readers?

Bruce
Guest
Bruce
1 year 5 months ago

Brad, it was a really great book.

salgak
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I still nomed “Christmas Noun 7” on my personal ballot for Best Short Story.

Because of the moaning and wailing and exploding of craniums that would result. And I had an extra slot on the slate. . . (grin)

John Rose
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

“Transhuman and Subhuman” was DEEP. John Wright’s prose is something to behold. Thus my purchase of “One Bright Star to Guide Them”

Already own Skin Game (actually, the entire Dresden Files series), a lot of MHI, the Grimnoir books, and Kloos’ books, so I’m bookmarking this for, ahem, future reference.

gregq
Guest
gregq
1 year 5 months ago

No David Weber? No John Ringo? No Tom Kratman?

The puppies I see are very sad.

gregq
Guest
gregq
1 year 5 months ago

Oh, and links would be good, esp for the “Related” items.

John R. Ellis
Guest
John R. Ellis
1 year 5 months ago

I would replace Grimm with The Flash for short-form dramatic presentation. For a CW show it’s been surprisingly faithful to the spirit of the source material, while reinventing it for a new audience.

(surreptitiously hides the vast pile of FLASH comics lurking in a corner.)

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

The Flash is great fun. I haven’t seen Grimm, so I can’t comment on how the two compare. But the team doing The Flash definitely deserve some acknowledgement.

Luke
Guest
Luke
1 year 5 months ago

The Librarians also deserves some love. It’s fantasy in the modern world, great pulp, and lots of fun.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

Librarians are EVIL! Just ask Alcatraz!

John R. Ellis
Guest
John R. Ellis
1 year 5 months ago

Given the “specific episode must be nominated” rule, if anyone wants to join in on nominating The Flash episode 9: “The Man in the Yellow Suit”…heh-heh-heh.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

Runner-up would be the episode that introduced Leonard Snart – aka Captain Cold.

But yes, “Man in the Yellow Suit” was a rather good episode.

Achillea
Guest
Achillea
1 year 5 months ago

I’d go with Grimm, myself. It’s an awesome show, and does fun and creative things with fairy tales (plus unlike the wretched OUAT, none of the characters is an annoying child). Plus diversity! Half of the characters aren’t even human!

I like The Flash and how they’re rebooting the source material, but found the Arrow pairing jarring. Arrow’s a lot more reserved and low-key with its superpowers, and it was rather like Superman Goes to Gotham.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

The current Arrow story arc with Ray Palmer is getting a bit more super-powery (albeit tech powers of the power suit variety). In fact, Felicity and Palmer will be appearing in an upcoming episode of The Flash. Apparently they’ll be heading to Star Labs to get some help with part of Ray’s ATOM suit.

John R. Ellis
Guest
John R. Ellis
1 year 5 months ago

Well, they’re being very careful and controlled in the expansion of the DC TV Universe. So back then other than Ollie, there wasn’t anyone Barry -could- get his backdoor pilot on. But, yeah, like junior said, Arrow season 3 has introduced the Atom, the Flash has introduced Firestorm (and teased a few others), sometime soon Vixen (!) is getting her own online mini-series in the same setting…so soon they’ll have enough for their own street level Justice League.

Lea
Guest
Lea
1 year 5 months ago

I had no idea they voted for tv shows on this! I adore Grimm.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago

There is a problem with one of the categories.

You can’t just name a show for best dramatic presentation (short form); you have to name a specific episode. Yes; it’s crazy but that’s how it works, and it usually means that a show needs a loud cheerleader to suggest a specific episode. This is how Dr. Who keeps getting more than one nomination.

Game of Thrones Season One was nominated as a single work, but that was in long form.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago

Ah, looking at Brad’s page, as of now, there are two shows with named episodes, but there are a couple more without.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago

How does Game of Thrones qualify as a work that would otherwise not find itself on the ballot? It won last year, and the year before that. It won as long form in 2012.

I have no problem nominating it, but it will probably make the ballot with or without Sad Puppies.

trackback

[…] his post which replaced his short story with a work by John C. Wright. // And Larry Correia has now posted his take on SP3. Considering how pleased he sounds about “getting the SJWs to have a giant public freak […]

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Well, they’re already accusing SP of “fascism” on Twitter (I posted some examples at Brad’s) and they’re not even on the ballot yet! Who knew they were such faithful readers of these blogs?

And speaking of Brad’s, look who popped up in the comments. 🙂

Kristophr
Guest
Kristophr
1 year 5 months ago

Fascism?

We aren’t a bunch of violent socialists. A real group of Fascists would show up on his doorstep, burn a pile of his books, and chase him around with axe-handles, while accusing him of treason against the true working man.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Judging by his Twitter feed, he uses “fascist” and “neocon” in a fashion that suggests he has no idea what either word means.

DaveP.
Guest
DaveP.
1 year 5 months ago

True fact: most of the folks who spend the most time referring to others as “fascists” neither have much of a clue about what a ‘fascist’ believes, nor would survive the attentions of any real, historical fascists. It’s just shorthand for “People who don’t agree with me politically” to them. Might as well be calling us “Star-Bellied Sneeches” for all the accuracy involved.

Pugmak
Guest
Pugmak
1 year 5 months ago

@Christopher M Chupik:

The SJWs use fascist, neo-con and nazi slurs with the exact same motivation that actual nazis use(d) “filthy jew!” and with the same intentions.

Lets not delude ourselves. If the SJWs ever reach critical mass, that movement will become just as mass murdery as the worst cases in history to date.

Kristophr
Guest
Kristophr
1 year 5 months ago

Pugmak:

All utopianists degenerate into death camp guards and/or inmates. A utopia requires the destruction of the original civilization. The result is always megadeaths.

Ygolonac
Guest
Ygolonac
1 year 5 months ago

I wonder how insane the WorldCon SJW crowd will be when I show up carrying a big (fake) tetsubo bearing the sign “Larry Correia Fan Club”? (I live in Spokane, not gonna miss out on this!)

Steve Diamond
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
Thanks for the love in the Fanzine dept., Larry. It’s nice to know people like Elitist Book Reviews. We dont care about politics or religion…we care about the quality of the stories. Dont forget my short story A Single Samurai is in The Baen Big Book of Monsters 😉 It’s awesome! Might i suggest one serious addition? William Schafer of Subterranean Press for Best Editor – Short Form. Like Stan Schmidt, Bill Schafer has been criminally ignored, and has been a huge reason for short fiction still existing in several genres. He also runs the best Specialty Press in the… Read more »
Pugmak
Guest
Pugmak
1 year 5 months ago

When ever I run into a book I think might be worth reading, but with an unfamiliar author, I head to your site first in looking for reviews.

I, for one, seriously appreciate the work y’all put into that site and the service you and your crew provide.

Geoff Whisler
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I just got an email back from Sasquan saying they got 600 apps in the last couple of days. Interpret that how you will. I’m nominating Ringo and “The Martian”….

Jeff Weimer
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I signed up a week ago and paid my money, but they haven’t sent me anything yet, not even an email acknowledging my membership. Is this kind of wait normal?

bassmanco
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

See Geoff Whisler’s post above. I received the same email about 600 last minute members and that it would take a week to process, and I signed up 1/28/15.

trackback

[…] noreply@blogger.com (Vox) Larry Correia has some comments on passing the Sad Puppies banner to Brad Torgersen:These are my suggested nominations. I am under […]

trackback

[…] Mr. Larry Correia describes on his blog his desire to retire from the Sad Puppies tempest in a thimble, but that certain evil forces dragged him back in. […]

James May
Guest
James May
1 year 5 months ago
The best thing one can do is keep using social justice warrior quotes and examples of their essays and fiction to point out this is a core group of witchhunting, shaming, sociopathic psychopaths who believe in the abolition of gender as if it were slavery. They honestly believe the genre of SFF has been a women-hating racist KKK for the entire century of its history, including right now. They believe the West is like the imperial Roman Empire because Coca-Cola and Harry Potter. That core of sociopaths is supported by naive nitwits who seem to actually believe they are marching… Read more »
av willis
Guest
av willis
1 year 5 months ago
Exodus is an interesting case because part of me thinks they sort of have a point,but not for the reasons they think. If you go back to the original scripture, we have indications that both Jethro and by extension Zipporah were black, the fact that Moses was “married to a Cushite” is listed as a reason for Miriam and Aaron falling out with Moses. I think in that context, portraying diversity makes sense. at the same time, go back and look at the original Heston films and tell me that nothing has changed. My biggest question, however, is where is… Read more »
James May
Guest
James May
1 year 5 months ago

The question is not one of whether there are black folks about; there are plenty in Cairo, though a minority. The question is whether that cast looks out of place and it does not, not at all. Given Egypt’s location on a map and Ramses II’s actual rock tomb memorial at Abu Simbel which depicts him riding his chariot over sub-Saharan Africans while he is depicted entirely differently gives no credence to belly-aching about the cast.

Austin
Guest
Austin
1 year 5 months ago

I’d like to point out the possibility of nominating Christopher Nuttall for the Campbell Award. Great new author, really got on the scene this year, though he’s been indie publishing for a few. I’m not 100% sure about the qualifications, though. Ebooks have rendered a lot of the rules of publishing outdated.

Craig
Guest
Craig
1 year 5 months ago

For fan writer, I’ll be going with Deirdre Saoirse Moen (Deirdre.net, which some of you may remember from her posts on MZB). Her posts on that were thoughtful and well done.

And not Dave Freer, because no offense to Dave, but he’s a full pro, and I want to preserve my ability to mock pro writers that seek fan nominations 🙂

Otherwise I want to have read things before I nominate, so I’ll have to go a-purchasing.

suburbanbanshee
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Yes, that was gutsy fanwriting. Although having good sources really helped her too.

LL
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I will say, I loved Tom Kratman’s Big Boys Don’t Cry. Most books blur together at some point, but there are some which stand out. That was one for me. Even if you don’t nominate him, at least read the book.

Viidad
Guest
Viidad
1 year 5 months ago

Agreed. Remarkably touching work.

wyrdbard
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
And this is a reason I’m looking at all the Sad Puppy (and variant) slates… and a good reason to put them out as clusters rather than just individual selections. I now have specific books and stories to read. Word of mouth is still one of the primary ways that books move. The Hugos used to be a way for Readers to say “Hey! Hey! You’ve got to read this book!” Right now Sad Puppies is serving that function… perhaps the Hugos will again in the future and maybe next year I’ll have enough free funds for a membership to… Read more »
Shadowdancer Duskstar / Cutelildrow
Guest

Yeah, I’m looking at the slate as a list of “Oh hey, I gotta read that…”

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Slatening. It rhymes with . . . hatening.

Viidad
Guest
Viidad
1 year 5 months ago

I will be nominating Monster Hunter Nemesis for best novel. I’m with John C. Wright on this one. Excellent book with serious depth.

John C Wright
Guest
John C Wright
1 year 5 months ago

Hear, hear and you rock, Viidad! Exactly right!

TCook
Guest
TCook
1 year 5 months ago
I signed up this year! Thank you for this entire sad puppies endeavor, which is actually how I learned anything at all about how the Hugos work or that I had the option to participate. I will definitely look into all your suggestions when I make my nominations I also hope some of you reading this might consider nominating Peter David’s _Artful_ which is a pretty awesome book set post-Oliver-Twist about the Artful Dodger fighting vampires – because it’s a fun and clever book and also because I was actually very surprised to realize that he has never won a… Read more »
lobo314
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I have a suggestion for the the slate fellow hunters. For Best Novel Pixie Noir by Cedar Sanderson. or the sequel Trickster Noir. 3rd and I think final one in the series will hopefully be out by Libertycon.. Larry I think you’ve met Cedar. I like her. she’s good people.It would tickle me pink to see her make it to the official ballot and trounce all comers.

Brian Marshall
Guest
Brian Marshall
1 year 5 months ago

I am saddened nothing by Brandon Sanderson is on there. He is my one of my favorite Authors up there with Larry and Butcher.

Brian Niemeier
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Writing Excuses’ fanbase has proven itself big enough to get works nominated. They’ll make sure his short story in Shadows Beneath makes the ballot.

Remember: Sad Puppies is for deserving artists/works that need an extra push to break through the usual WorldCon voters’ ideological roadblocks.

Brian Niemeier
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

“…keep in mind, one of our goals this time was to put forward worthy authors who have been ignored by the typical Hugo voting crowd.”

Good point–and one of the main reasons I joined SP3.

You’ll get no argument from me about Brandon’s worthiness (if SP2 didn’t prove your point about corruption at the Hugos, WoT’s loss clinched it). Also, you’re obviously right that he doesn’t need our help to get nominated.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago

(if SP2 didn’t prove your point about corruption at the Hugos, WoT’s loss clinched it).

Corruption in what sense? Are you suggesting that votes for WoT weren’t counted?

Brian Niemeier
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

“Corruption in what sense? Are you suggesting that votes for WoT weren’t counted?”

No. Larry said that his audit of last year’s WorldCon ballots showed that the administration was on the level, and that’s plenty good enough for me.

I’m referring to the dominant voting bloc tainted with SJW ideology–which Sad Puppies, and Wheel of Time’s loss, proved beyond a reasonable doubt.

Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago
I’m referring to the dominant voting bloc tainted with SJW ideology–which Sad Puppies, and Wheel of Time’s loss, proved beyond a reasonable doubt. I know Larry predicted a big victory for WoT, but the whole series was eligible as a single work last year because in hadn’t managed to get nominated once since 1990. I’m guessing you’ve been a big fan from the beginning. I didn’t read it when it came out. A friend who is a fan of the series, suggested that it probably wasn’t my deal. After it was nominated, I read one volume and stopped there. I… Read more »
Brian Niemeier
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
“I’m guessing you’ve been a big fan from the beginning.” Until somewhere around Book 5. I haven’t finished the series yet. I’m familiar with Mr. Sanderson’s work from other books, and that’s how I’m judging his craftsmanship. My point regarding Wheel of Time is that the Hugos are a popularity contest, WoT enjoys the most popularity by far among last year’s nominees, therefore its loss strongly suggests that the Hugos don’t represent SFF fandom as claimed. “I think there is plenty of room for reason for reasonable doubt about why it didn’t do better that doesn’t have anything to do… Read more »
Khazlek
Guest
Khazlek
1 year 5 months ago
My point regarding Wheel of Time is that the Hugos are a popularity contest, WoT enjoys the most popularity by far among last year’s nominees, therefore its loss strongly suggests that the Hugos don’t represent SFF fandom as claimed. It depends on how you define SFF fandom. I think you are saying that WoT enjoys the most popularity among SF readers. You may be right. Do SF collectible catalogs still sell WoT swords and stuff like that? I suspect that WoT isn’t as popular now as it was some years ago. In any case, I think it is likely true… Read more »
Brian Niemeier
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Jason Rennie’s two appearances on the slate have me all kinds of excited!

And I couldn’t agree more about Toni. An editor’s job is to pick winners. Toni’s success in that regard speaks for itself.

Eccentric Cowboy
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
I never tire of you rattling the cages of the SJW Collective, and this is an official way to do it. I look forward to seeing more of these morons come out of the woodwork! I really should check out some of these other authors though. Sounds like they would be a real blast! Time to set aside some more reading money. 🙂 Of course, when I read the mention of “no dinosaur love story” my brain instantly went “Does a story involving the love of hunting dinosaurs count? Cuz I’d totally enter some of my stuff into that category.”… Read more »
Daniel Speyer
Guest
Daniel Speyer
1 year 5 months ago

Eric S Raymond seems decidedly unconvinced of his nomination.

Which reminds me, Larry: any response to ESR’s earlier SF and the damaging effects of literary status envy?

TomT
Guest
TomT
1 year 5 months ago

I’m torn Larry, Skin Game Versus Monster Hunter Nemesis. As much as I like MHN I think I might got Skin Game.

Leit
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

You and a lot of other folks… including, I suspect, Larry himself.

No offense at all to Larry, but Butcher’s stories have so much pull that dragging yourself away from the page is like trying to exit Earth’s gravity well by vigorously flapping your arms.

I’m quite happy to sit at a lagrange point between him and Larry, though.

Jeff Gauch
Guest
Jeff Gauch
1 year 5 months ago

I face a similar dilemma. I’m going to vote for MHN just to watch the SJW reaction to a Correia win.

There will be plenty of opportunities to give Butcher well-deserved Hugos when the Dresden Files movies start coming out.

Shadowdancer Duskstar / Cutelildrow
Guest

Oh man. I’d LOVE to see Dresden Files movies. They just need to pick a VERY good actor to portray Harry. Kinda like how, IMHO, Robert Downey Jr. was the perfect Tony Stark, and whoever decided to cast Hemsworth and Hiddleton for Thor and Loki is a freaking GENIUS. Get that person to pick for the Dresden Files movies PLEASE.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

Keep in mind that there was a Dresden TV series. And it didn’t last very long.

Jeff Gauch
Guest
Jeff Gauch
1 year 5 months ago

There was a TV show called “The Dresden Files.” It didn’t bear much similarity to the books.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

I would still sooner do Dresden on TV than the movies. You could do 3-4 novels a season.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

The Dresden TV series had an odd episode turn up around episode 8 that was much closer to the original novels. I think what happened is that by that point the powers that be had already decided the show wasn’t going to get renewed. So they used the original pilot (which hadn’t aired) as a filler episode to save money.

If my theory is correct, then the show as originally conceived would have been much closer to the novels. But somewhere along the way a number of elements (such as Harry’s VW, and Susan Rodriguez) were removed.

Jared
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I’m pretty sure that was the pilot.

Really sad too, it was a bit rushed to get the first book in, but it did a lot better than the rest of it.

Granted, I still enjoyed the show, but only by completely divorcing it from the books in my mind.

trackback

[…] a surprise to see my name turn up on the infamous Sad Puppies slate and on Brad Torgersen’s, Larry Correia’s, and Vox Day’s […]

herbn
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

(lots of suggestions for it, but the Martian wasn’t eligible).

I’ll admit disappointment here. A coworker lent it to me last week and the ability to push it pushed me over the edge on joining Sad Puppies this year (although I’m glad I did regardless). It was the best near future sci-fi I’ve read in 20 years, easily.

protaganis
Guest
protaganis
1 year 5 months ago
Oh man! Asking me to choose between Skin Game and Nemesis?! That’s like asking me to choose between my favorite Universal monsters (Dracula vs Frankenstein) 😉 Both books were my favorites for the year! I do have to say, after having tried reading a Hugo award winning novel several years ago, I gave up on them. I remember throwing the book down thinking “The soul is gone, if crap like this makes it…” I’m happy to see that you’re bringing back the love to an award that got me interested in books like Enders Game. Fight the good fight! I’m… Read more »
allenquatermain
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

I’m glad to see Tangent on the ballot. I write reviews for them occasionally and Dave is a stand up guy. I’m a little surprised to see ‘The Maze Runner’ on there though, considering how window-licking idiotic that movie was.

trackback

[…] Brad Torgersen’s site, Vox Day’s site (although he’s calling it Rabid Puppies), Larry Correia’s, and my friends over at the Mad Genius Club. To all of them I say, “Oh wow, this is awesome! […]

judgedeadd
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
And I’m still kicking myself I didn’t think to suggest Sam Hughes’s “Ra” (available at qntm.org/ra) earlier. Despite having decidedly leftist and atheist views, he keeps them out of his fiction, filling his stories with robots and supercomputers and planets being blown up and time travellers and superpowers, as opposed to heroic lesbian SJWs oppressed by homophobic Catholics. It would be fun to see if this heretofore obscure writer would suddenly become a target of SJW vitriol just because they cannot wrap their heads around the possibility that we are, in fact, capable of enjoying things written by people we… Read more »
Rolf
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Any reason for only four Campbell nominees?
Vox has me (The Stars Came Back, 119 Amazon reviews, ~3500 copies sold) on his list. It’s been nominated for a Prometheus, and that alone should give Scalzi & Co a coronary.

Wes S.
Guest
Wes S.
1 year 5 months ago

Good to see you’re working on a sequel to “The Stars Came Back,” Rolf. For that matter, I’d actually love to see someone turn it into a movie or miniseries, especially since you’ve done most of the work for them, script-wise… 😉

rolfnelson42
Guest
rolfnelson42
1 year 5 months ago

Believe me, I’d love to see a movie / miniseries out of it too. Not just for the $$, though that would be great, but I’d love to have something on the screen that I’d actually want to go see. So many theaters, so much potential, so much crap.

rolfnelson42
Guest
rolfnelson42
1 year 5 months ago

Any particular reason for only four Campbell nominees?

Vox has me (Rolf Nelson, “The Stars Came Back”, 119 Amazon reviews, ~3500 copies sold, originally indie now with Castalia House) on his list. It’s been nominated for a Prometheus Award by the Libertarian Futurist Society, which by itself should give the militant left coronaries. No reason not to fill all possible spots on the slate.

rolfnelson42
Guest
rolfnelson42
1 year 5 months ago

Blag-drag-it. Sorry for the double-post. wordpress/browser/something problem.

Shawna
Guest
Shawna
1 year 5 months ago
As far as TV shows, I agree with Grimm, but I think OUAT deserves some recognition, too. I think that’s a great show. Really liking the new show Forever, but I don’t know if that’s eligible or if it’s too new. Totally agree that Guardians of the Galaxy should at least get a nom, though I kinda think it should win. It was just all-around excellent. (Although I do agree with the feminists that the “whore” line was inappropriate. One small blemish on an otherwise perfect movie.) Skin Game gets my vote for novel, though. Obviously. It was freaking amazing.… Read more »
John R. Ellis
Guest
John R. Ellis
1 year 5 months ago
Re: Guardians The line was spoken by Drax, who (at least in the movieverse) has as a major character trait that he constantly misunderstands the world around him and spouts off weird, wildly inappropriate things. From his intro right to the coda where he still doesn’t quite understand why “murder” is Something that Exists. I’m willing to give Gunn the benefit of the doubt that depicting the character doing that was not the same thing as excusing or advocating it. Anymore than, say, Rocket mocking the grief of widowers was an attempt to legitimatize anti-widower sentiments. If I’m wrong, may… Read more »
Shawna
Guest
Shawna
1 year 5 months ago
I just think that, given that the female character had shown no tendency toward sexuality or promiscuity, it kind of came out of nowhere. If he’d used the word ‘bitch’ instead, it would have, in my opinion, been much more fitting. It would have been just as insulting/rude, but would have fit with the fact that she’s a tough chick instead of insinuating that he, for no reason, thinks that she is promiscuous. And given that his species is entirely literal, it seems like for him to call her a whore, he’d actually have to believe that she was literally… Read more »
ravenshrike
Guest
ravenshrike
1 year 5 months ago

@shawna
Drax was repeating what he overheard the prison horde yelling about Gamora. Unless we’re supposed to suddenly assume the inhabitants of a supermax prison in space are all clean-spoken choirboys, that line was PERFECTLY in character both for Drax and the scene itself

Arwen
Guest
Arwen
1 year 5 months ago

Ehh, I gave up on OUAT mid season three. I felt like the writers were just jerking the audience along, trying to squeeze in as many Disney cameos as possible.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Reaction to Sad Puppies here:

http://amazingstoriesmag.com/2015/02/dont-run-bag-might-puppies/

Unlike many others, he’s read what Larry said, but he still doesn’t understand.

James May
Guest
James May
1 year 5 months ago
He understands well enough. He got a taste of the inquisition when he ran a Felicity Savage piece about “diversity” and decided on the better part of valor. He has decided to join Orwell’s Sandbox where words like “harassment” and “racism” are as malleable as clay and always end up looking straight at the new villain in radfem’s phantom march on Selma, the ethnic European male unlucky enough to be born a heterosexual. Davidson has been forced to adopt Audre Lorde’s vision of what SFF should look like while pretending such a thing doesn’t even exist. To do otherwise and… Read more »
steve davidson
Guest
steve davidson
1 year 1 month ago

Mr. May,
I’m other things in addition to being “white” (which according to the US census options I am not) and “male”, I am many other things, including intelligent and capable of making choices in a reasoned manner, something that apparently eludes many commenting here.
No surprise. Look where I am.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 1 month ago

Out of curiosity, why is Mr. Davidson here, precisely?

Luke Powell
Guest
Luke Powell
1 year 5 months ago

I haven’t seen any mention of Sanderson’s Words of Radiance, which I thought was a fantastic book. Is that not eligible for some reason? I did sign up as a supporter, so I’ve got to figure out what all the rules are for voting.

Christopher M. Chupik
Guest
Christopher M. Chupik
1 year 5 months ago

Nominate whatever you want, as long as it was published in the last year. These are just guidelines. Vote with your conscience.

junior
Guest
junior
1 year 5 months ago

iirc, Sanderson was briefly mentioned above. He’s not on Larry’s list because he’s probably not going to need any help getting nominated.

Guess
Guest
Guess
1 year 5 months ago

Larry… If you get nominated will you attend worldcon?

Wallbanger7110
Guest
Wallbanger7110
1 year 5 months ago

And, thinking ahead for Sad Puppies 4, MidAmeriCon in 2016 is in my neck of the woods – may be the only chance I get to meet/get autograph from you (unless you come to KC for a book tour before then)!

Jared
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Oh. wow. just, lol.

Anyone else notice how the village idiot views the group?

“Damien Walter ‏@damiengwalter

Science fiction award under attack by religious fundamentalists. It could almost be the plot of a Philip K Dick novel.”

And later…

“Damien Walter @damiengwalter · 15h 15 hours ago

If we’re “lucky” some Islamic fundamentalists will decide to hijack the Hugo award as well and they’ll cancel the Christian fundies out.”

Funny, and here I thought my favorite authors were a varied and diverse bunch who are everything from Mormon and Catholic to Atheist and Asatru.

Kristophr
Guest
Kristophr
1 year 5 months ago

The Asatru fundamentalists would laugh at Damien, and then hang him as a sacrifice to Odin.

James May
Guest
James May
1 year 5 months ago
The Locus recommended nomination list is a good example of what’s happening even in institutions that are pretending to maintain principles. Like Tor.com in general, that Locus list attempts and succeeds in being majority apolitical. The problem with each is they have this pesky group of idiotic supremacists they will not call out or get rid of. How do I know that’s true? I know it’s true because if Tor and Locus had authors who were openly supportive of Stormfront, the KKK and neo-Nazism I know they wouldn’t last one second at either place. The problem is one of principle,… Read more »
YellowSubmariner
Guest
YellowSubmariner
1 year 5 months ago
Dunno if you knew this, but Butcher was actually attacked by the SJWs a few years ago. In book 7 of the Dresden Files, Harry goes to Hyde Park, which is a neighborhood in Chicago. He describes it as a blend of the worst the city has to offer with the best it has to offer (the latter being the University of Chicago) Some people felt that this was racist because it played into ‘black neighborhood=high crime=worst parts of the city’ tropes. Butcher complained about this on twitter, and he got attacked for objecting to the criticisms. See: http://luciazephyr.dreamwidth.org/548703.html and… Read more »
YellowSubmariner
Guest
YellowSubmariner
1 year 5 months ago

Btw, as a random factoid, Mikki Kendall/Karnythia (who runs the ‘Esoterica’ tumblr I linked above) is currently co-editing an SFF anthology called “Long Hidden 2” which is described here: http://longhidden.com/2014/09/17/long-hidden-2-is-coming/ .

She was also the editor in charge of the short-lived “Verb Noire” small press which spun out of Racefail: http://www.verbnoire.com/editors . The collapse of the company is discussed here: http://mcclernan.blogspot.sg/2013/12/what-did-mikki-kendall-do-with-verb.html .

60guilders
Guest
1 year 5 months ago

Are these people insane?
Do they have lives beyond their grievances?
Or have they simply become walking, talking grievance bundles?
The sheer amount of willful ignorance, reading comprehension failure, and sheer oversensitivity is appalling.

speaker4thedead
Guest
1 year 5 months ago
I agree with tons of things around here… but not about KJA. I LOVED him when i was a kid back in the 90s (his Star Wars and X-Files books were sooo much fun for me!). Grew up reading a ton of his books… but after rereading a lot of it, and reading a lot of his new stuff. It feels bad. I went and read all the NEW Dune books he and the younger Herbert put out of the last 15 or so years and they read well, but thinking about them afterwards and trying to read them a… Read more »
Jason
Guest
Jason
1 year 5 months ago

I just defaulted almost exactly to this list. I added a short story by MZW. I will be reviewing my Amazon purchase history to see what changes I might want to make, but if I forget, at least I’m fucking with the Hugos.

Kit
Guest
Kit
1 year 5 months ago

Dave Creek asked to be taken off the list.

trackback

[…] are awarded by SF Fandom at large – anyone can vote. There’s a group of conservative authors (led by Larry Correia) who feel that the awards are too liberal and intellectual nowadays, and are leaving out the SF […]

perlhaqr
Guest
perlhaqr
1 year 5 months ago
Plus, John Wright said that MHN was my best book Now, that’s just not true. Actually, frankly (sorry, buddy.) I kind of think MHN was a little weak. It seemed more like setup work for the upcoming stuff than most of your books do. Which isn’t to say that I disliked it, or disliked reading about Frank’s origin and back story, but… I dunno. Just, compared to MHA, I would definitely not call MHN your best work. *shrug* Anyway, yeah, I’ll probably vote for Skin Game. Because seriously, Butcher made me feel bad for the most evil human (thus far)… Read more »
trackback

[…] pretty much exclusively from a fan campaign called Sad Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Last year, Correia organized a campaign which successfully placed one item in each category on the […]

trackback

[…] pretty much exclusively from a fan campaign called Sad Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Last year, Correia organized a campaign which successfully placed one item in each category on the […]

trackback

[…] from a fan marketing campaign referred to as Unhappy Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Final yr, Correia organized a marketing campaign which efficiently positioned one merchandise in […]

Matt G
Guest
Matt G
1 year 3 months ago
You know, it’s a funny thing– I’ve read Larry Correia’s stuff for a few years. Not all of it, but probably 2/3 of what he’s put out. It’s fun, pleasurable reading. It’s actually pretty tight in places– more so than I expected. I have read some criticism of his works by people who have declared him to be racist, among other things. I can’t figure out where this comes from. I’m pretty sensitive to racism. I don’t like it, and don’t care to be around it. One of my few hot-buttons that I have to watch out for over-reacting at… Read more »
Fred
Guest
Fred
1 year 3 months ago

Sigh. I get as annoyed as the next straight white guy at constantly being demonized, but this is just silly. I agree the Hugo’s are broken, but you’re breaking them even worse. I enjoy your books a lot, and a lot of the books on your slate, but I’m seriously considering boycotting your books out of disgust – I cannot take anyone who uses the phrase SJW to describe their opponents seriously. You should be fuckin’ ashamed.

trackback

[…] pretty much exclusively from a fan campaign called Sad Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Last year, Correia organized a campaign which successfully placed one item in each category on the […]

trackback

[…] açıklandığında bazı bilim kurgu, fantastik yazarları ve okuyucuları itiraz etmişti. Larry Correia ve Brad R. Torgersen sitelerinde “elit azınlığın” BKF kültürünü […]

trackback

[…] pretty much exclusively from a fan campaign called Sad Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Last year, Correia organized a campaign which successfully placed one item in each category on the […]

trackback

[…] difficult to track down a single good quote that summarizes what has been wrong with the Hugos but this seems to come pretty close. It is unclear to me that Deirdre and Rick Moen ever actually refute the […]

trackback

[…] From February, when the slate was first announced: […]

trackback

[…] pretty much exclusively from a fan campaign called Sad Puppies, organized by Brad R. Torgersen and Larry Correia. Last year, Correia organized a campaign which successfully placed one item in each category on the […]

trackback

[…] the movements.* Correia in particular appears unperturbed by the Gamergate-SP connection. On his blog, he refers to his progressive enemies as SJWs (“social justice warriors,” a Gamergate coinage […]

trackback

[…] SAD PUPPIES 3: The Slatening? […]

wpDiscuz